The number that fights back
French numbers become a small lesson in how a language's official form can be an absurd historical accident. Up to sixty everything behaves; then 70 is soixante-dix (60+10), 80 is quatre-vingts (4×20), 90 is quatre-vingt-dix (4×20+10), 91 is quatre-vingt-onze (4×20+11), a base-20 fossil that makes a learner do arithmetic to count. The twist that makes it a teaching: Swiss, Belgian, and Canadian French quietly fixed it with septante, huitante, nonante. The 'official' system isn't the optimal one, it's the one that stuck, and the regional variants are the sane ones.
// trace: where this idea came from
- ↳ video diary @ 2:14 (del 70 en adelante se complica todo)
- ↳ video diary @ 1:14 (el francés de Suiza y Canadá los normalizó)
French numbers deliver a small, sharp lesson: a language’s official form can be an absurdity that simply outlasted the alternatives. Up to sixty, everything behaves, vingt, and the tens march normally. Then, Juan reports, “desde el 70 para adelante se putea todo” ▸ 2:14. Seventy is soixante-dix, sixty-and-ten. Eighty is quatre-vingts, four-twenties. Ninety is quatre-vingt-dix, four-twenties-and-ten, and ninety-one is quatre-vingt-onze, four-twenties-and-eleven ▸ 3:42. It’s a base-20 fossil that makes a beginner do arithmetic just to count, and he’d rather memorize five clean words than run those sums ▸ 2:32.
lo oficial no es lo óptimo; es lo que quedó →
The twist that turns a complaint into a teaching is that the mess was already fixed, just not in France. Swiss, Belgian, and Canadian French use septante, huitante, nonante, plain and regular ▸ 1:14, so the same language runs a sane number system a border away. It’s the smallest possible proof of a thesis Severo keeps bumping into, that a curriculum’s official standard is a convention, not a law of nature: the version that got canonized isn’t the optimal one, it’s the one that stuck, and the regional variants are often the reasonable ones. When a language makes you multiply by twenty to say ninety, the right lesson isn’t to admire the tradition. It’s to notice who quietly refused it…
// continued in
no entry has continued this idea yet: the arc is still open